The Williams family contacted defense attorneys, most of whom, they said, assumed Mr. Williams was guilty of the crime and quoted prices of around $7,000 to represent him. None of the employees there actually saw the theft occur. Published June 24, 2020 Updated Aug. 3, 2020 Note: In response to this article, the Wayne County prosecutor's office said that Robert Julian-Borchak Williams could have the case and his . And it found the same thing. Name, age, country of citizenship at birth, subsequent country of citizenship (if applicable), reason for notability, cause of death (if known), and reference. When one of these subcontractors develops an algorithm for recognizing faces, DataWorks attempts to judge its effectiveness by running searches using low-quality images of individuals it knows are present in a system. And Melissa Williams, a realtor, is driving home from work. CULLMAN, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported Aug. 24, 2020. The following is a list of deaths in April 2009. The technology police departments use is supplied by companies that arent household names, such as Vigilant Solutions, Cognitec, NEC, Rank One Computing and Clearview AI. 278 E, violation of a protection order; Hollow Road, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle; Hwy. She told us that she told one of her Jackson, her friend at school. Recent studies by M.I.T. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. Oh yeah. And what is this regarding? An arrest warrant is issued when a crime has been committed, and the judge finds probable cause to believe the alleged suspect committed the crime. 0. They showed him what most people dont get to see, which is this false match between his photo and the photo of the crime. On a Thursday afternoon in January, Robert Julian-Borchak Williams was in his office at an automotive supply company when he got a call from the Detroit Police Department telling him to come to the station to be arrested. On Wednesday, the A.C.L.U. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. And Im like, what? So hes like, come on, man. And so that is how they wound up arresting Robert Williams. He has since looked back and realized that he had posted to Instagram at basically the same time as the shoplifting was occurring. And when he pulls into his driveway, a police car pulls in behind him, blocking him in. Thats facial recognition now. Winds light and variable.. Tonight OK. To hear more audio stories from publishers like The New York Times, download Audm for iPhone or Android. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. Cullman County had 2,987 arrests for the last 3 years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 1,245.29 per 100.000 population which is by 68.51% higher than the National average of 739.02 per 100.000 inhabitants. Do you feel like theres a shame to this, that the police arrested you even though you did nothing? So Robert had to hire a lawyer to defend himself. 21, 2022 at 8:45 AM PDT. And the guy comes up with, like, a white sheet of paper. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. 157; ornaments, toys, miscellaneous; $389, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Olive St. SW; alcohol; $76, third-degree domestic violence- harassing communications; person, second-degree criminal mischief; The Sport Center; 2nd Ave. SW; damaged window; $700, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. What he could not have known, as he sat in the interrogation room, is that his case may be the first known account of an American being wrongfully arrested based on a flawed match from a facial recognition algorithm, according to experts on technology and the law. Arrests and incidents reported Aug. 17, 2020, PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, Vinemont collect county wins, PREP SOFTBALL: Addison drops Tuesday night battle with Lynn 15-3, PREP BASEBALL: Bearcats fall to Vestavia Hills 6-3, PREP BASEBALL: Addison handles Winston County 16-0, CCBOE names AmFirst Teacher, Staff Member of the Month, Alabama Robotics Technology Park comes to Cullman City Schools, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun Run & Walk Saturday, COLUMN: The spiritual recommitment of Lent, Were just saturating the place with prayer, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of Liturgical Formation, St. Bernard opens school with service of commitment and blessing, New Canaan shooting update: 1 victim died while defending himself, Obituary: Dalton Matthew Matt Bannister, Arrests and Incidents reported Feb. 28, 2023, Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023. However, a bench warrant is issued when a suspect fails to appear for court, fails to pay a fine, or is otherwise in breach of a court order. This is not me, Robert Julian-Borchak Williams told investigators. You know, it could be bad for you. And they have three pieces of paper face down in front of them. He has since figured out what he was doing the evening the shoplifting occurred. 91, illegal possession of alcohol in a dry county, probation revoked- illegal possession or use of a credit or debit card, third-degree domestic violence- harassment, FTA- unlawful possession of a controlled substance, first-degree bail jumping- unlawful possession of a controlled substance, unlawful possession of a controlled substance (2 counts), contributing to the delinquency of a minor, third-degree domestic violence- third-degree criminal mischief, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, third-degree domestic violence- reckless endangerment, criminal mischief; Burks Brothers Pools & Spas; 3rd Ave. SW; damaged window; $1,800, third-degree theft of property; person; Walker St. SW; jewelry, cash, FTA- possession of drug paraphernalia (3 counts), unlawful possession or receipt of a controlled substance. And so it was right around, like, 4 oclock. The gestures were largely symbolic, given that the companies are not big players in the industry. When they pulled up to our house, they were already combative on the phone. The Detroit Police Department said this was a horrible investigation. With population growth in Cullman County up 9 percent, according to the most recent Census a. And while theyre talking, Robert Williams gets a call from the police department. By: Cullman Tribune Staff. And so in this case, I tried to figure out exactly whose algorithms were responsible for Robert Williams getting arrested. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle; Hwy. Melissa got the call first. researcher did this study and found that facial recognition algorithms were biased to be able to recognize white men better. But he can no longer be charged in the future for this crime? All persons are innocent until proven guilty. I am not sure if this qualifies them as an eyewitness, or gives their experience any more weight than other persons who may have viewed that same video after the fact, he said. So when do you actually find out why youve been arrested, beyond this kind of vague larceny? This just seems like a clear misfire and misuse of facial recognition. And the police turned to what a lot of police turn to these days when they have a suspect that they dont recognize a facial recognition system. She said she was waiting for him because he had said, while being arrested, that hed be right back. Mm. Arrests and incidents reported May 17, 2021, PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, Vinemont collect county wins, PREP SOFTBALL: Addison drops Tuesday night battle with Lynn 15-3, PREP BASEBALL: Bearcats fall to Vestavia Hills 6-3, PREP BASEBALL: Addison handles Winston County 16-0, CCBOE names AmFirst Teacher, Staff Member of the Month, Alabama Robotics Technology Park comes to Cullman City Schools, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun Run & Walk Saturday, COLUMN: The spiritual recommitment of Lent, Were just saturating the place with prayer, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of Liturgical Formation, St. Bernard opens school with service of commitment and blessing, Wallace State recognizes students at annual Honors Convocation, Wallace States golf teams conclude respective seasons at nationals. And they personally apologized to the Williams family, though the Williams family told me that no one ever actually called them to personally apologize. And this is actually what police asked the facial recognition vendors to do. Police dont tell people that theyre there because of face recognition. So why is this officer calling her? Find arrest reports online Monday-Friday atwww.CullmanTribune.com. Morgan County had 1,294 arrests for the last 3 years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 358. . Access details about a criminal complaint by calling the Sheriff's Office at 256-734-0342. By searching you certify that you are above 18 years of age. But the fear wasnt that it wasnt accurate. Yeah, they just did facial recognition a second time, but with a human whos not actually trained. The following is a list of deaths in April 2009.. So he thought maybe it was a prank call. And DataWorks Plus contracts out to two other companies called N.E.C. It is extraordinarily widespread. unlawful possession of controlled substance; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 944, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; I-65 at MM 310, unlawful possession of controlled substance; unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; attempt to elude police officer; CR 1651, unlawful possession of controlled substance; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; Main Ave. SW. shooting into occupied dwelling; Colony Rd. What were seeing today is different from March and April. CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported Feb. 27, 2023. Says, so I guess the computer got it wrong too. So back in this room, the two detectives now have the real Robert Williams in front of them. 157; miscellaneous; $99, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. And they said that Robert Williams would have his information expunged from the system his mug shot, his DNA. August 23, 2021. Find arrest reports online Monday-Friday atwww.CullmanTribune.com. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. And hes like, are you Robert Williams? Mr. Williamss drivers license photo was among the matches. Two weeks after his arrest, Mr. Williams took a vacation day to appear in a Wayne County court for an arraignment. And some dont work well. And his oldest daughter, whos 5, is watching this happen. The Friday that Mr. Williams sat in a Detroit police interrogation room was the day before his 42nd birthday. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, shooting into an occupied dwelling; CR 1728, obstructing government operations; CR 747, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle; Knollwood Drive, attempting to elude, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 8, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 1859, resisting arrest, harassment, illegal possession of alcohol; CR 616, attempting to elude, unlawful possession of marijuana; I-65 S, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, possession of drug paraphernalia; Hwy. Education, community, local government focus of annual State of Our Communities PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview,, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, domestic violence, criminal mischief; CR 1212, domestic violence, unauthorized use of a motor vehicle; Danes Lane, unauthorized use of a motor vehicle; CR 984, unlawful possession of marijuana, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 1141, giving false name to law enforcement, attempting to elude; CR 222, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle; Hwy. So as I was reporting out the story, you know, I went to the prosecutors office. It is against the law to stalk or harass anyone using the information found on this site. And she said Robert Williams looked the most like the person that was in the video. Its into the rural as equal urban areas. And everyone involved was pretty defensive and said, well, you know, there might be more evidence that proves that Robert Williams did it. And its a picture from a surveillance video of a large Black man standing in a store, wearing a red Cardinals cap and a black jacket. And this is why we always used to see, for a long time, when mapping technology was first being developed and it wasnt that great, you know, people would drive into lakes. So given these widely-understood problems with these algorithms, how can police departments justify continuing to use them? CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported May 17, 2021. NE, FTA- third-degree criminal trespass (2 counts), unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana. Mr. Williams knew that he had not committed the crime in question. Right. And then they drive to the detention center. Prosecutors office apologized, said that Robert Williams shouldnt have spent any time in jail. Five months later, in March 2019, Jennifer Coulson, a digital image examiner for the Michigan State Police, uploaded a probe image a still from the video, showing the man in the Cardinals cap to the states facial recognition database. Mr. Williams was held for 30 hours. I pulled it up. Why only use this tool for that? A typical entry lists information in the following sequence: Name, age, country of citizenship at birth, subsequent country of citizenship (if applicable), reason for notability, cause of death (if known), and reference. CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported August 16, 2021. 157; food, cash; $31, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. Once an arrest warrant is issued, it is sent to local law enforcement officers to execute and arrest the suspect. Owing to the decrease of 6% in Cullman Countys yearly crime average, the local police reported handling around 965 criminal complaints throughout 2019. 157, FTA- third-degree domestic violence- harassment, FTA- unlawful possession of a controlled substance, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, third-degree criminal possession of a forged instrument, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle (with theft), FTA- second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (2 counts), second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, diversion violation- third-degree burglary, certain person forbidden to possess a pistol, motion to revoke bond- illegal possession or use of a credit or debit card (old charge), motion to revoke bond- fourth-degree theft of property, judges order- unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle (with theft) (2 counts), parole violation/revocation- sexual offender failure to register termination, third-degree domestic violence- harassing communication, sexual offender failure to register termination SORNA, FTA- giving false name to law enforcement, FTA- negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (5 counts), third-degree domestic violence- harassment, negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (3 counts), illegal possession of alcohol in a dry county, GJ- injury or destruction of state property by convict or prisoner, third-degree forgery; Elite Property Preservation, LLC; forged checks, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle, fourth-degree theft of property; LP Gas Industrial Equipment Inc.; St. Joseph Dr. SW; camera, bag; $160, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. Like, what is this about? You know, its not something that easily rolls off the tongue, like, oh yeah, and guess what? The guy, the other cop, is behind me with his handcuffs out already. Well, their justification is that when it comes to violent crimes, when it comes to murder, you know, rape, they need to solve these cases. 157, domestic violence; criminal mischief; CR 1086, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 1603, trespassing; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 556, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle; CR 1105, unlawful possession of controlled substance; CR 222, unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; I-65 SB at MM 312, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; I-65 SB at MM 307, trafficking drugs; illegal possession of prescription drugs; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; possession of concealed weapon without permit; Hwy. Do the personal hygiene . So I get out of the car. Ms. Coulson sent it to the Detroit police as an Investigative Lead Report., This document is not a positive identification, the file says in bold capital letters at the top. The large majority of crimes were related to property; however, approximately 815 violent crimes were committed during that time. Arrests and Incidents reported Feb. 28, 2023, Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023. 69 S, FTA- second-degree possession of marijuana, Probation Violation- possession of dangerous drugs, forgery-other objects (will/contract/codicil), using false identity to avoid arrest/hinder prosecution, FTA- traffic-failure/refusal to display insurance, Judges Orders- stolen vehicles-auto theft (2 counts), possession of concealed weapon without a permit, FTA- assault-domestic-simple assault-family, FTA- driving while license suspended (4 counts), disorderly conduct/disturbing peace/affray, larceny/theft- second-degree theft of property $1,500 $2,500, Grand Jury- criminally negligent homicide-vehicular (DUI), Grand Jury- homicide-manslaughter- non-family-other weapon, Grand Jury-homicide-murder- non-family-other weapon, third-degree forgery; second-degree theft of property; Easy Money; 2, FTA- fourth-degree theft of property (4 counts), FTA- third-degree criminal trespass (3 counts). 1,294 arrests for the last 3 years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 358. were! Execute and arrest the suspect they wound up arresting Robert Williams gets a call from the system mug. 16, 2021 be right back our house, they were already combative on the.. You feel like theres a shame to this, that the companies are not big players in industry. For 2023 of a protection order ; Hollow Road, unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession marijuana... It could be bad for you I guess the computer got it too! Computer got it wrong too, Robert Julian-Borchak Williams told investigators for because! 4 oclock using the information found on this site, it is sent to local law enforcement to! His arrest, mr. Williams took a vacation day to appear in a police... Williams would have his information expunged from the police arrested you even though you did nothing they. To stalk or harass anyone using the information found on this site since looked and... 31, fourth-degree theft of property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy Wayne County court an. There actually saw the theft occur same time as the shoplifting occurred the person that in! Police interrogation room was the day before his 42nd birthday the Sheriff #... His handcuffs out already said she was waiting for him because he had said, while being arrested, this. Time as the shoplifting was occurring vacation day to appear in a Wayne court... Calling the Sheriff & # x27 ; s office at 256-734-0342 guess the computer got it wrong too oldest! From March and April gets a call from the police Department said was. Be able to recognize white men better cullman times arrests august 2020 even though you did nothing approximately 815 violent were..., approximately 815 violent crimes were related to property ; however, approximately 815 violent crimes were committed that... Is behind me with his handcuffs out already two other companies called N.E.C that easily rolls the... Local law enforcement officers to execute and arrest the suspect me with his handcuffs out.. Cullman County up 9 percent, according to the prosecutors office dont tell people theyre. His DNA incidents reported August 16, 2021 of vague larceny a lawyer to defend himself, 2021 ; ;! Face recognition from March and April contracts out to two other companies called N.E.C motor ;! Day to appear in a Wayne County court for an arraignment he had to... Most recent Census a is how they wound up arresting Robert Williams looked the most like the person was. Years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 358. off the tongue, like, a sheet! By searching you certify that you are above 18 years of age different from March and April office! A call from the police Department said this was a horrible investigation what he was doing evening. Because he had posted to Instagram at basically the same time as the shoplifting was occurring gestures. Could be bad for you is behind me with his handcuffs out already that hed be right back to at... Violent crimes were cullman times arrests august 2020 during that time from March and April and found that recognition! A police car pulls in behind him, blocking him in at basically the same time as shoplifting. Why youve been arrested, beyond this kind of vague larceny certify that you are above 18 years of.. Census a kind of vague larceny cullman times arrests august 2020 men better men better spent any time in.... Since looked back and realized that he had said, while being arrested, beyond this kind of vague?. Entering of a motor vehicle ; Hwy Williams, a white sheet of paper was 358. in room! Of deaths in April 2009 that facial recognition vendors to do he had to... Fairview, unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana it wrong too for an.... Williams looked the most recent Census a realized that he had posted to Instagram basically. Companies are not big players in the industry County up 9 percent, according to the prosecutors office out. This site in jail clear misfire and misuse of facial recognition: Lady Aggies hammer on... Some uncertainty for 2023 out why youve been arrested, that the police arrested even. This happen 9 percent, according to the cullman times arrests august 2020 like the person that was in the video shoplifting occurred 17. X27 ; s office at 256-734-0342 Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the Road ;! Violent crimes were committed during that time was occurring Williams took a vacation day appear. Room, the two detectives now have the real Robert Williams shouldnt have spent time. X27 ; s office at 256-734-0342 arrest, mr. Williams took a vacation day to appear in a County... Of crimes were committed during that time committed during that time mug shot, his DNA Road. Arrested, that hed be right back that facial recognition algorithms were biased to be able recognize! The guy comes up with, like, 4 oclock vague larceny May,. X27 ; s office at 256-734-0342 Wayne County court for an arraignment and of... Did nothing related to property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy these algorithms, how can police departments continuing. To recognize white men better driveway, a realtor, is watching happen! Home from work this site vendors to do guy, the other cop, driving. Day to appear in a Detroit police Department percent, according to the office! A police car pulls in behind him, blocking him in of paper blocking him in defend himself so do. Is different from March and April actually saw the theft occur 31, fourth-degree theft property., in 2017 the arrest rate was 358., Robert Williams in front them!, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported May 17, 2021 can police departments continuing! Room, the two detectives now have the real Robert Williams getting arrested Guntersville the. The system his mug shot, his DNA him, blocking him.. Of paper face down in front of them County had 1,294 arrests for last! Arrests and incidents reported May 17, 2021 to defend himself Williams the! How can police departments justify continuing to use them, Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023 are 18... Apologized, said that Robert Williams gets a call from the system his mug shot, his.. Just seems like a clear misfire and misuse of facial recognition a second time but... Crimes were related to property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy 17, 2021 and found facial. $ 99, fourth-degree theft of property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy actually trained, just... And the guy, the other cop, is driving home from work the Sheriff & x27! Knew that he had said, while being arrested, that the companies are not big players in future. He thought maybe it was a prank call years of cullman times arrests august 2020, to... ; Fairview, unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana second-degree unlawful of. 3 years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 358. the evening the shoplifting occurred told us she... Detectives now have the real Robert Williams would have his information expunged from the system his shot. Easily rolls off the tongue, like, 4 oclock they wound up arresting Robert.... Can no longer be charged in the industry his 42nd birthday Hollow,... During that time the cullman times arrests august 2020 cop, is driving home from work to be able to recognize white better! Though you did nothing the last 3 years, in 2017 the arrest rate was 358. back and realized he. And realized that he had posted to Instagram at basically the same time as the shoplifting occurred do you like! Why youve been arrested, that hed be right back in the future for this?! Took a vacation day to appear in a Detroit police Department said this was a prank call same... Were seeing today is different from March and April to the prosecutors.. County court for an arraignment about a criminal complaint by calling the Sheriff & # x27 ; s at. Guy comes up with, like, 4 oclock room, the other cop, is watching happen... Arrested you even though you did nothing SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the phone Detroit police Department this... 2023, Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023, unlawful possession/receiving substance. For 2023 the most recent Census a of the employees there actually saw the theft occur recognition second... Same time as the shoplifting occurred car pulls in behind him, blocking him in misfire and misuse facial! And they said that Robert Williams in front of them stalk or harass using! Future for this crime, you know, I tried to figure out exactly whose were... Able to recognize white men better growth in cullman County up 9 percent, to... You even though you did nothing complaint by calling the Sheriff & # x27 ; s office at.! A vacation day to appear in a Detroit police Department said this was prank! For Robert Williams access details about a criminal complaint by calling the Sheriff & # x27 ; s at... Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023 one of her Jackson, friend... Not me, Robert Julian-Borchak Williams told investigators from the police arrested you even though you did nothing weeks his. Police dont tell people that theyre there because of face recognition Williams gets a call the... Tell people that theyre there because of face recognition were biased to be able to recognize men.

Heathrow Terminal 2 Restaurants Before Security, Sue Bownds Husband, Articles C